Breastfeeding On Demand vs. Scheduled Feeding

Breastfeeding on Demand vs Schedule

Breastfeeding is a natural and beautiful way to nourish your baby. As a new mom, you may find yourself bombarded with conflicting advice on how often and how long to breastfeed.

Should you follow a strict schedule or let your baby dictate the feeding times?

In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the benefits and considerations of both breastfeeding on demand and scheduled feeding. Let’s dive in!

What is Breastfeeding on Demand?

Breastfeeding on demand, or responsive feeding, is a feeding approach where you breastfeed your baby whenever they show signs of hunger.

Instead of adhering to a rigid schedule, you follow your baby’s cues and allow them to feed when needed.

These cues can include licking their lips, sticking out their tongue, rooting, or sucking on their hands.

Advantages of Breastfeeding on Demand

Breastfeeding on demand offers numerous benefits for both you and your baby. Firstly, it helps establish a robust milk supply.

The more frequently your baby breastfeeds, the more milk your body will produce.

This is particularly important in the early days after birth when your milk supply is still being established.

Additionally, breastfeeding on demand ensures that your baby receives enough milk to promote healthy growth and development.

Breastfeeding is not just about providing nutrition; it is also a source of comfort and bonding for you and your baby.

By breastfeeding on demand, you meet your baby’s emotional needs and foster a strong mother-baby connection.

The Flexibility of Breastfeeding on Demand

One of the significant advantages of breastfeeding on demand is its flexibility. It allows you to respond to your baby’s individual feeding preferences and patterns.

Every baby is unique, and their appetite can vary from day to day.

By breastfeeding on demand, you can ensure your baby gets the nourishment they need without rigidly adhering to a specific schedule.

What is Scheduled Breastfeeding?

Scheduled breastfeeding, as the name suggests, involves feeding your baby at predetermined intervals.

Instead of waiting for hunger cues, you establish a routine based on factors such as your baby’s weight or age.

Some parents find comfort in having a set schedule, as it provides a sense of predictability and allows them to plan their day accordingly.

Advantages of Scheduled Breastfeeding

Scheduled breastfeeding can have some advantages, particularly for parents who prefer a more structured approach.

It can help establish a routine for both you and your baby, making it easier to manage your daily activities.

Additionally, some babies thrive on predictability and may feel more secure with a consistent feeding schedule.

Importance of Feeding Cues and Flexibility

While scheduled breastfeeding may work for some families, it is crucial to remain attentive to your baby’s feeding cues and be flexible when needed.

Babies grow and develop at different rates, and their feeding needs can change rapidly.

It is essential to be responsive to your baby’s cues and adjust the feeding schedule accordingly.

Ignoring hunger cues can decrease milk supply and hinder your baby’s weight gain.

Finding the Right Balance

The Early Weeks: Breastfeeding on Demand

In the first few weeks after birth, breastfeeding on demand is highly recommended.

Newborns have small stomachs and must feed frequently to meet their nutritional needs.

Aim to breastfeed your baby at least 8-12 times in 24 hours. This frequent feeding will stimulate your milk production and ensure your baby receives enough nourishment.

During this time, it’s normal for babies to cluster feed, which means feeding more frequently for a period of time.

This cluster feeding helps increase your milk supply and gives your baby the extra nourishment they need during growth spurts.

Establishing a Routine: Transitioning to Scheduled Feeding

As your baby grows and becomes more efficient at breastfeeding, they may naturally settle into a more predictable feeding pattern.

Around 1-2 months of age, most babies will nurse 7-9 times a day. This is when you can start considering a transition to scheduled feeding if it aligns with your preferences.

When transitioning to scheduled feeding, it is essential to do it gradually.

Start by introducing a consistent feeding interval every 2-3 hours.

However, always remain responsive to your baby’s hunger cues and adjust the schedule if necessary.

The Importance of Weight Gain and Growth

Monitoring your baby’s weight gain and growth is crucial, regardless of whether you choose breastfeeding on demand or a scheduled approach.

Regular check-ups with your pediatrician will help ensure your baby is thriving and meeting their developmental milestones.

If your baby is not gaining weight adequately or showing signs of hunger, it may be necessary to adjust your feeding routine.

The Role of Your Baby’s Development

It’s important to remember that every baby is unique and will develop at their own pace.

As your baby grows, they will start establishing their own feeding patterns and preferences.

Some babies may naturally fall into a routine, while others may continue to prefer feeding on demand.

It’s essential to be in tune with your baby’s unique needs and adjust your approach accordingly.

Tips for Successful Breastfeeding

Establish a Supportive Environment

Creating a supportive environment is crucial for successful breastfeeding, regardless of your chosen feeding approach.

Surround yourself with a network of professionals and loved ones who can provide guidance and encouragement.

Reach out to lactation consultants or breastfeeding support groups for additional support.

Learn to Recognize Hunger Cues

Understanding your baby’s hunger cues is essential for responsive feeding. Look out for signs such as lip licking, tongue protrusion, rooting, or sucking on hands.

By responding promptly to these cues, you can ensure that your baby receives timely nourishment.

Follow Your Instincts

As a parent, trusting your instincts and developing a strong bond with your baby is important.

Pay attention to their unique needs and preferences and decide what feels right for both of you.

Remember, there is no one-size-fits-all approach to breastfeeding.

Seek Professional Guidance

If you have any concerns or questions about breastfeeding, don’t hesitate to seek professional guidance.

Lactation consultants, pediatricians, and breastfeeding support groups can provide valuable advice and support to help you navigate your breastfeeding journey.


Breastfeeding is a deeply personal and individual experience for every mother and baby.

Whether you choose to breastfeed on demand or follow a scheduled approach, what matters most is that you and your baby are thriving.

Finding a feeding routine that aligns with your family’s needs and allows for flexibility and responsiveness to your baby’s cues is essential.

Remember, the key to successful breastfeeding is creating a nurturing and loving environment that supports you and your baby throughout your breastfeeding journey.

The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Do not disregard or delay seeking professional medical advice because of something you read in this article.


  • Cam Russo

    Cam is a blogger, author, and content strategist with a keen love for the written word. His journey with high-functioning autism has kindled a strong advocacy for autism awareness. Today, Cam dedicates his efforts to educating parents. He sees laughter as a game-changer in learning, and strives every day to make education a fun and enjoyable journey for all his readers.

    View all posts
Previous articleHow to Help a Gassy Baby Sleep
Next articleWhen Do Babies Need Bibs?
Cam Russo
Cam is a blogger, author, and content strategist with a keen love for the written word. His journey with high-functioning autism has kindled a strong advocacy for autism awareness. Today, Cam dedicates his efforts to educating parents. He sees laughter as a game-changer in learning, and strives every day to make education a fun and enjoyable journey for all his readers.